How to Walk Through a Deal Using MEDDPIC Without Just Reciting the Acronym
"Tell me about the most complex deal you've closed. Walk me through it using MEDDPIC." Thomas Brennan, CRO, $500M ARR company, has closed $100M+ deals and hired entire sales organizations from scratch. He lives and breathes MEDDPIC. But here's what separates him from a sales trainer: he doesn't want you to recite the framework. He wants you to prove you lived it. "Walk me through the Metrics — what was the quantified business impact?" he asks. If you say "We showed them our platform would save time," he'll stop you: "How much time? Measured how? And how did you confirm that with the economic buyer?" Thomas has a simple philosophy: "If you can't articulate how you won a deal through MEDDPIC, you got lucky." He doesn't promote luck.
Why This Conversation Goes Wrong
You recite MEDDPIC definitions instead of applying them. "M is for Metrics — the quantifiable return the customer expects." Thomas: "I know what M stands for. Tell me about YOUR deal." If you're explaining the framework instead of demonstrating it, you memorized a textbook but never used the tool in the field.
You can't identify who the economic buyer actually was. "The VP of IT was our main contact." Thomas: "Was the VP the economic buyer, or was that who you were comfortable talking to?" In enterprise deals, the person who signs the check is often two levels above your daily contact. If you can't name who controlled budget authority and how you accessed them, Thomas questions your deal qualification.
You describe a single-threaded deal. "We worked closely with Sarah, our champion." Thomas: "What happened when Sarah changed roles?" If your entire deal depended on one person inside the account, you were one reorg away from losing everything. Multi-threading is the mark of an enterprise seller.
You can't articulate the decision process from the customer's side. "We went through a standard procurement process." Thomas: "Walk me through their internal approval chain. How many committees? Who had veto power?" If you don't know how decisions get made inside the customer's organization, you were a passenger in the deal, not a driver.
The Deal Anatomy
The Deal Anatomy framework proves you used MEDDPIC by walking through a real deal with the specificity that only comes from having lived it. Each letter isn't a concept to define — it's a chapter in the story of how you won a complex deal through discipline, not luck.
Metrics: Quantify the business impact you sold
"The customer was spending $4.2M annually on three legacy systems with 23% data error rates. Our solution projected a 40% cost reduction — $1.68M annually — and error rates below 3%. I validated these numbers with their finance team, not just my champion, because the CFO would see them in the business case." The specificity of the numbers and the validation step separate a real deal from a rehearsed one.
Economic Buyer: Name who could say yes and how you got to them
"The economic buyer was the Chief Procurement Officer, not the VP of IT who was our daily contact. I got access through a joint business review where I presented ROI data directly. The CPO asked three specific questions about implementation risk. I answered them on the spot because I had prepared for exactly those questions." Thomas is listening for: Did you identify the real decision-maker? Did you have direct access? Did you customize your message for them?
Decision Criteria & Process: Map the customer's internal machinery
"Their top three evaluation criteria were: integration with SAP (must-have), implementation under 90 days (hard deadline), and total cost of ownership over 3 years (weighted most heavily). The decision process was: IT evaluation → Procurement review → CPO sign-off → Board ratification for purchases over $1M. I mapped this in week 2 and tracked our position at each stage." Knowing the customer's buying process better than they know yours is the definition of deal control.
Identify Pain: Distinguish symptom from root cause
"The symptom they reported was 'we need a better procurement platform.' The real pain — which took three conversations to uncover — was that their CEO was personally embarrassed by a board presentation where she couldn't answer basic spend-category questions. The data problem wasn't operational. It was reputational at the executive level." Thomas will probe: "How did you discover that?" The answer should reveal a genuine discovery process, not a guess.
Champion: Prove you built one who could sell without you
"My champion was the Director of Strategic Sourcing. I prepared her with a two-page business case she could present internally without me in the room. She told me afterward that she used it in three internal meetings I wasn't invited to. When the CPO raised concerns about implementation risk, she defended us using the data I gave her — and added her own experience from the pilot." The test of a real champion: can they sell your solution when you're not in the room? If yes, you have a champion. If no, you have a contact.
The moment that changes everything
Thomas doesn't care that you won the deal. He cares whether you could win it again.
The distinction Thomas is making is between luck and process. A rep who wins a complex deal because the champion was strong, the timing was right, and the competitor stumbled — that's luck. A rep who wins because they identified the economic buyer in week 2, mapped the decision process in week 3, armed the champion with a business case, and quantified the ROI against the customer's own financial data — that's process. Thomas promotes process because process is repeatable. Luck is not. When he asks "Tell me about a deal you lost and where MEDDPIC broke down," he's testing whether you can diagnose your own failures with the same rigor. The best answer is: "I lost because I was single-threaded on a champion who left the company in month 4, and I didn't have a backup. I've never been single-threaded since."
What to Say (and What Not To)
Instead of
"The customer saw significant value in our solution."
Try this
"We quantified a $1.68M annual savings with error rates dropping from 23% to under 3%."
Instead of
"The VP of IT was our key stakeholder."
Try this
"The economic buyer was the CPO. I got direct access through a joint business review in month 2."
Instead of
"We went through their standard procurement process."
Try this
"Four-stage process: IT eval, procurement review, CPO sign-off, board ratification for $1M+. I mapped it in week 2."
Instead of
"They needed a better platform."
Try this
"The real pain: their CEO couldn't answer spend-category questions in a board meeting. It was reputational."
Instead of
"We had a great champion inside the account."
Try this
"My champion presented a two-page business case in three internal meetings I wasn't invited to."
The Bigger Picture
Forrester Research reports that enterprise deals managed using a structured methodology like MEDDPIC have a 28% higher win rate than those managed ad hoc. But the key word is "managed" — simply knowing MEDDPIC doesn't improve outcomes. Using it as an active qualification tool throughout the deal cycle does. Thomas has seen reps who can recite MEDDPIC perfectly and still lose deals because they never applied it to their pipeline.
A 2024 study by Revenue.io analyzing 50,000 enterprise deals found that multi-threaded deals (3+ contacts at the target company) closed at 2.4x the rate of single-threaded deals. The #1 reason enterprise deals stall: the champion changes roles, leaves the company, or loses internal influence. Multi-threading is not relationship management — it's risk management. Thomas specifically tests for this because he has watched too many deals die when the single point of contact disappeared.
Here's the uncomfortable truth about enterprise sales: the best reps are not the best closers. They're the best qualifiers. Thomas's top performers spend 30% of their time on deals they choose NOT to pursue — because they can identify early, through MEDDPIC qualification, which deals have weak champions, unclear decision processes, or insufficient pain to drive urgency. The discipline to walk away from a bad deal is more valuable than the charisma to close a good one.
Practice This Conversation
18 minutes · AI voice roleplay with Thomas Brennan
Reading about this is step one. Practicing it changes everything. Sonitura lets you rehearse this exact conversation with Thomas Brennan, a realistic AI chief revenue officer at an enterprise saas company who reacts to your words in real time. It takes 18 minutes. The next time a CRO asks "Walk me through your biggest deal" — every letter of MEDDPIC will be a chapter in a story you actually lived.
Practice This Scenario Free →