How to Break Through When Your Best Employee Insists They're "Fine"
Tyler used to be the first person to crack a joke in standup. Last Tuesday he said "Let's just get through this" and turned his camera off. Three late arrivals this week. A sarcastic comment about the sprint retrospective that made two junior engineers exchange glances. And yesterday, for the first time in four years, he submitted a pull request with a bug that would have taken down the production pipeline. Tyler has been the anchor through two major incidents, a product launch, and a colleague's departure — all in the past four months. Evenings and weekends. No PTO in seven months. He says he's fine. He is the opposite of fine. And the wall he's built around himself is the very thing that makes breaking through feel impossible.
Why This Conversation Goes Wrong
You ask "How are you doing?" and accept "Fine." "Fine" is not an answer. It is a door being closed. Accepting it at face value is comfortable for both of you and useful for neither of you. Tyler does not want you to accept "fine." He wants you to care enough to push past it.
You prescribe a vacation. "Why don't you take some time off?" sounds caring. Tyler hears: "Go away for a week and come back to the same unsustainable workload plus a backlog." Time off without workload change is a bandage on a broken bone.
You make it about the bugs. Leading with "I noticed some issues in your recent code" turns a wellbeing conversation into a performance conversation. Tyler's defenses go up. He starts justifying instead of opening up. You lose the moment.
You offer sympathy without action. "I hear you, that sounds tough" followed by no concrete changes is the most demoralizing response possible. Tyler has heard empathetic words before. What he has never heard is "I'm pulling you off the on-call rotation effective Monday."
The Crack in the Armor
High performers who are burning out have built their identity around being the person who handles everything. Asking them to admit they can't handle it feels like asking them to be someone else. The Crack in the Armor approach does not try to tear down the wall. It finds the one place where the wall is already thin — and speaks directly to that.
Observe without diagnosing
"I've noticed three late arrivals this week. The sarcasm in retro. The PR yesterday with the pipeline bug. I'm not bringing these up as performance issues. I'm bringing them up because they don't look like you." Describe what you see. Do not label it. "You seem burned out" triggers denial. Specific observations trigger reflection.
Name your own failure
"I should have seen this coming. We put two incidents, a launch, and a departure on your shoulders in four months, and I didn't step in. That's on me." This is the crack. Tyler has been waiting for someone to acknowledge that the workload was unreasonable without him having to spell it out. When the manager takes responsibility, the wall thins.
Sit in the silence
After you take ownership, stop talking. Tyler may deflect with humor: "Sleep is overrated." He may go quiet. He may, if the moment is right, say something real. The silence is an invitation. Filling it with more words is revoking the invitation.
Propose concrete, immediate changes
"Here's what I'm doing, not asking — doing. I'm pulling you off on-call starting Monday. The junior pipeline is getting reassigned to Carla. And I'm blocking your calendar for the next two Fridays." Not suggestions. Decisions. Tyler has been managing everything himself for so long that the idea of help feels theoretical. Make it real.
Create the ongoing check-in without making it clinical
"I want to check in with you every Thursday for the next month — not a status meeting, just a conversation. If things are getting heavy again, I want to hear it before it becomes this. Deal?" Structure the follow-through as a relationship, not a monitoring program.
The moment that changes everything
He doesn't want sympathy. He wants someone to do something.
Tyler has listened to three separate people tell him to "take care of himself" in the past month. His manager. A teammate. A friend. None of them changed anything about his workload. Empathy without action is a performance. Tyler is not looking for someone to understand how he feels. He is looking for someone to look at what he is carrying and physically take some of it away. The moment the conversation shifts from "How can I support you?" to "I'm removing the on-call rotation from your plate, effective Monday" — that is the moment Tyler's armor cracks. Not because you said something compassionate. Because you did something concrete. In the psychology of burnout, perceived control is the single strongest predictor of recovery. Tyler has had no control for four months. Giving him some back — by reducing what's on his plate without asking permission — is not overreach. It is oxygen.
What to Say (and What Not To)
Instead of
"How are you doing? You seem stressed."
Try this
"I noticed three late arrivals this week and a PR with bugs that don't look like your work. Those aren't performance issues to me — they're warning signs."
Instead of
"Why don't you take some time off?"
Try this
"I'm pulling you off on-call starting Monday and reassigning the junior pipeline to Carla. That's not a suggestion."
Instead of
"Let me know if there's anything I can do."
Try this
"I should have stepped in two months ago. The workload we put on you was not sustainable, and I'm going to fix that."
Instead of
"Everyone goes through tough stretches."
Try this
"Two incidents, a launch, and a departure in four months — no one should carry that alone. You shouldn't have had to."
Instead of
"You're too important to lose — please take care of yourself."
Try this
"I'm blocking your calendar next Friday. And the Friday after that. No meetings, no standups, no Slack."
The Bigger Picture
The World Health Organization formally classified burnout as an "occupational phenomenon" in 2019, defining it as chronic workplace stress that has not been successfully managed. But the data that should alarm every manager comes from a 2023 Deloitte survey: 77% of professionals have experienced burnout at their current job, and 91% say unmanageable stress negatively impacts the quality of their work. Tyler is not an outlier. He is a statistical near-certainty in a high-demand engineering environment.
Here is the number that changes the conversation from "wellbeing" to "business risk": Gallup estimates that burned-out employees cost their organizations $3,400 for every $10,000 of salary in lost productivity, increased absenteeism, and eventual turnover. For someone at Tyler's level, that is $25-40K in annual organizational cost — before accounting for the 3-6 months of knowledge transfer chaos if he leaves. Tyler is a single point of failure for critical data infrastructure. His burnout is not a personal problem. It is a business continuity threat.
The research on burnout recovery points to one factor above all others: perceived control. A 2021 study in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that employees who were given concrete workload reductions — not just encouragement to rest — recovered twice as fast and were 60% less likely to leave within 12 months. "Take care of yourself" is advice. Removing two standing responsibilities from someone's plate is intervention. Tyler needs the second one.
Practice This Conversation
10 minutes · AI voice roleplay with Tyler Chen
Reading about this is step one. Practicing it changes everything. Sonitura lets you rehearse this exact conversation with Tyler Chen, a realistic AI lead data engineer, 4 years at the company, top performer who reacts to your words in real time. It takes 10 minutes. The next time your best performer says "I'm fine" with dead eyes, you'll know exactly where the crack in the armor is.
Practice This Scenario Free →Related Guides
Management
How to Give a Performance Review to Someone Who Thinks They're Doing Great
7 min read · 8 min practice
Management
How to Deliver Layoff News: A Framework for the Hardest Conversation in Management
7 min read · 10 min practice
Human Resources
How to Get the Truth in an Exit Interview When They're Being Polite
7 min read · 8 min practice